Independent FEMA Public Assistance resource. Not affiliated with FEMA.Start hereReform trackerContact
Get technical assistance
Home / Laws & Policy / PAPPG Explorer / Appendix G
PAPPG v5.0 · Appendix G · pages 289–296

Alternative Procedures for Permanent Work

Section 428 alternative procedures fund large permanent work projects on a fixed, capped estimate instead of actual costs, in exchange for more flexibility: less cost tracking, funds you can move between projects, and savings you can keep for other eligible uses. This appendix covers how the fixed estimate and offer work, the deadlines, what fixed and excess funds can pay for, scope changes, closeout, appeals and audits.

6 topicsLarge projects onlyAccept the offer within 30 daysOverruns not funded; savings can be kept
Jump to a part of the chapter
Appendix G › V. Other Considerations: Insurance; Appeals; Office of Inspector General

Can we appeal an alternative procedures project, and do insurance and audit rules still apply?

Obtain and maintain insurance; appeals for alternative procedures projects; OIG
pp. 295–296
Short answer
Generally no appeals. FEMA only hears appeals of cost adjustments made after you accept the offer, such as for insurance, noncompliance or audits, and not appeals of denied extensions to accept an offer. The obtain-and-maintain insurance requirement still applies, and the DHS Inspector General can audit any alternative procedures project.
What FEMA requires
  • Insurance: applicants receiving permanent work funding must obtain and maintain insurance on insurable facilities and property (buildings, contents, equipment, vehicles), including those funded through alternative procedures (see FP 206-086-1).
  • Appeals: FEMA does not grant appeals on alternative procedures projects, except for cost adjustments after the offer is accepted (such as insurance, noncompliance or audits). Disagreements over damage, scope or cost must be resolved before accepting. Denied extensions to accept an offer can’t be appealed.
  • Inspector General: the DHS OIG can audit any project, including alternative procedures projects.
Documentation

Proof that you obtained and maintain insurance on facilities funded through alternative procedures, and full procurement and cost records, since the OIG can audit these projects.

Watch out · Govstar advice
Accepting the fixed cost offer effectively ends your ability to dispute damage, scope or cost. Treat the acceptance decision like a settlement and have your engineer and cost estimator sign off first.
PAPPG v5.0 pp. 295–296 · 44 CFR 206.203(d) · FP 206-086-1
Read this in the PAPPG
Appendix G › Scope of Work Changes; Closeout Requirements

When do we need FEMA’s approval to change the scope, and how do alternative procedures projects close out?

Alternative procedures scope of work changes; closeout requirements
pp. 294–295
Short answer
After you accept the offer, notify FEMA before changes involving buildings 45 years or older, ground disturbance, or work in or near water. Routine changes like material substitutions or new floor plans don’t need notice. At closeout, the recipient certifies the work and costs within 180 days, with a final report; you don’t track costs line by line.
What FEMA requires
  • Notify FEMA before scope changes that involve buildings or structures 45 years or older, ground-disturbing activities, or work in or near waterways.
  • Except for buildings 45 years or older, changes that substantially conform to the approved scope (material substitutions, interior floor plan reconfigurations) don’t require notice.
  • Changes affecting hazard mitigation must be approved within the 18-month deadline, and the fixed amount is adjusted.
  • Work must be complete by the approved deadline. The recipient certifies that incurred costs relate to the approved scope and that work followed FEMA rules.
  • The recipient submits its certification within 180 days of the subrecipient completing its last alternative procedures project or the latest project deadline, whichever comes first, for the subrecipient to keep excess funds.
  • Subrecipients don’t track costs to specific line items; they substantiate and certify that claimed costs relate to the overall eligible work.
<table class="pt-table"><thead><tr><th>Change after the offer is accepted</th><th>Notify FEMA first?</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Work on buildings or structures 45 years or older</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Ground-disturbing activities</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Work in or near waterways</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Changes that substantially conform (material substitutions, interior floor plan changes)</td><td>No (except on buildings 45+ years old)</td></tr><tr><td>Changes affecting the hazard mitigation scope</td><td>Must be approved within the 18-month deadline; fixed amount adjusted</td></tr></tbody></table>
Documentation

The recipient’s closeout certification with a final cost report covering: actual work completed, mitigation achieved, EHP compliance, civil rights compliance, obtain and maintain insurance compliance, total actual costs, procurement compliance, and actual insurance proceeds.

Watch out · Govstar advice
The recipient’s 180-day certification is what lets you keep excess funds, so make sure your final cost report and compliance records are ready well before then.
PAPPG v5.0 pp. 294–295
Read this in the PAPPG
Appendix G › IV. Use of Funding; Excess Funds

What can we spend fixed cost funds and excess funds on?

Use of fixed cost and excess funds
pp. 292–294
Short answer
Fixed cost funds can be shared across all your alternative procedures projects for repairs, replacement, new facilities (including land), equipment and cost-effective mitigation. Once that work is done, excess funds can also pay for mitigation on undamaged facilities, insurance premiums, training, disaster planning and PA staff salaries, but never for debt, operating costs, budget gaps or the local cost share.
What FEMA requires
  • Fixed cost funds may be shared across all alternative procedures projects for repair, restoration or replacement; new facilities including land acquisition; equipment; or cost-effective hazard mitigation.
  • If mitigation funding is included, you must complete the approved mitigation scope to keep that funding.
  • Excess funds may be used, once the approved scope is complete, for cost-effective risk reduction and to improve future PA operations or planning, as shown in the table.
  • Submit a proposed scope and timeline for excess funds to the recipient within 90 days of completing your last alternative procedures project; the recipient forwards it to FEMA within 180 days. You can request an extension.
  • FEMA reviews proposed uses for reasonableness and sets a completion deadline within the disaster’s period of performance.
  • Category I projects cannot be included in alternative procedures projects. All work must otherwise be PA-eligible.
<table class="pt-table"><thead><tr><th>Work or cost</th><th>Fixed cost funds?</th><th>Excess funds?</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Restoring disaster-damaged facilities and equipment</td><td>Yes</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Alternate projects in declared areas (equipment, new facilities, improving undamaged facilities such as shelters and EOCs)</td><td>Yes</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Cost-effective mitigation for undamaged facilities</td><td>No</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Future insurance premiums, including obtain and maintain requirements</td><td>No</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Response and recovery training, including grants management and procurement courses</td><td>No</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Planning for future disasters (debris, mitigation, recovery and emergency plans, exercises)</td><td>No</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Salaries for PA or emergency management staff</td><td>No</td><td>Yes</td></tr><tr><td>Facilities ineligible for failing earlier obtain and maintain requirements</td><td>No</td><td>No</td></tr><tr><td>Paying down debt, operating expenses, budget shortfalls</td><td>No</td><td>No</td></tr><tr><td>Non-federal cost share of FEMA or other federal awards</td><td>No</td><td>No</td></tr></tbody></table>
Documentation

A proposed scope of work and timeline for any excess funds, submitted to the recipient within 90 days of completing your last alternative procedures project, and the recipient’s submission to FEMA within 180 days.

Watch out · Govstar advice
Excess funds have their own clock: a proposed scope and timeline to the recipient within 90 days of finishing your last alternative procedures project. Missing it can cost you the savings, so plan the excess-fund uses before the last project closes.
PAPPG v5.0 pp. 292–294 · Table 36
Read this in the PAPPG
Appendix G › III. Fixed Cost Offer; Fixed Cost Offer Deadlines

How does the fixed cost offer work, and what are the deadlines?

Fixed cost offer; fixed cost offer deadlines
pp. 291–292
Short answer
FEMA sends the estimate as a fixed cost offer in Grants Portal. You and the recipient have 30 days combined to accept it, and the agreement must be reached within 18 months of the declaration. Once accepted, the project can’t go back to standard procedures, overruns aren’t funded, and any savings become excess funds you can use.
What FEMA requires
  • FEMA works with engineers, architects, cost estimators and construction managers to develop or validate the estimate, then transmits it as a fixed cost offer through Grants Portal.
  • If accepted, the project is an alternative procedures project. Obligation is FEMA’s acceptance of the fixed amount.
  • FEMA treats the fixed amount as reasonable and eligible if there is no fraud and you comply with grant conditions, including procurement. Insurance proceeds and salvage values are credited.
  • After agreement there are no further adjustments except for insurance and approved hazard mitigation scope changes. FEMA’s cost estimating format includes contingencies for hidden damage, unforeseen environmental and permitting requirements, and other unknowns.
  • If you need only architecture and engineering first, you must define the actual scope of work before a fixed cost offer is sent.
<table class="pt-table"><thead><tr><th>Step</th><th>Deadline or rule</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Reach a fixed cost agreement</td><td>Within 18 months of the declaration date</td></tr><tr><td>Accept a fixed cost offer</td><td>Recipient and applicant combined: 30 days from FEMA’s transmittal</td></tr><tr><td>Not accepted in time</td><td>Processed under standard procedures on actual costs</td></tr><tr><td>Extension to accept</td><td>Approved by FEMA’s Assistant Administrator for Recovery before the deadline</td></tr><tr><td>Once accepted</td><td>Cannot revert to standard procedures</td></tr><tr><td>Costs over the fixed amount</td><td>Not funded</td></tr><tr><td>Costs under the fixed amount</td><td>Excess funds may be used for eligible purposes</td></tr></tbody></table>
Documentation

FEMA’s fixed cost offer and its transmittal date; your and the recipient’s acceptance within 30 days; and any extension approved by FEMA’s Assistant Administrator for Recovery before the deadline.

Watch out · Govstar advice
The 30 days is shared between you and the recipient, so agree internally how many days each side needs. Settle every dispute over damage, scope and cost before accepting, because accepted alternative procedures projects generally can’t be appealed.
PAPPG v5.0 pp. 291–292
Read this in the PAPPG
Appendix G › II. Fixed Cost Estimate

How is the fixed cost estimate for an alternative procedures project built?

Fixed cost estimate; expert panel cost estimate review
pp. 290–291
Short answer
First FEMA, the recipient and you agree on the damage, the scope of work and any hazard mitigation. The estimate then covers restoring the facility to pre-disaster design and function under eligible codes, plus cost-effective mitigation tied to the work you will actually do. It can include design, environmental review, permitting and construction management costs.
What FEMA requires
  • FEMA, the recipient and the applicant must agree on the damage description and dimensions, scope of work and hazard mitigation before the fixed cost estimate is developed, by FEMA or by you.
  • Funding is capped at the federal share of the estimated cost to restore to pre-disaster design and function under eligible codes and standards, plus cost-effective mitigation tied to the restoration work actually performed.
  • Allowable costs: architectural, engineering, environmental review and design fees; construction and other restoration costs, including permitting fees, project or construction management, and required codes, consensus-based codes and approved industry standards.
  • Expert panel: a FEMA-funded independent panel of cost experts may review estimates. It addresses cost only, not eligibility, and is not used for appeals. FEMA may request it for any estimate; you may request it for projects with an estimated federal share of at least $5 million.
  • Hazard mitigation: mitigation is a separate fixed amount in the subaward tied to the actual work planned. If capacity is increased, mitigation is limited to protecting the original capacity. If the approved mitigation isn’t completed, FEMA reduces the fixed amount by that portion.
Documentation

The agreed damage description and dimensions, scope of work and hazard mitigation proposal; design, permitting and construction management cost information; and code and standard requirements.

Watch out · Govstar advice
Everything must be agreed before the estimate is built, so negotiate the damage description and scope hard up front. For projects with a federal share of at least $5 million, you can ask for the independent expert panel to review the estimate.
PAPPG v5.0 pp. 290–291
Read this in the PAPPG
Appendix G › I. Differences Between Standard and Alternative Procedures

What are alternative procedures, and how are they different from standard procedures?

Alternative procedures for permanent work (Stafford Act Section 428)
pp. 289–290
Short answer
Under Section 428 alternative procedures, FEMA funds large permanent work projects on a fixed, capped estimate instead of actual costs. You get more flexibility: less itemized cost tracking, funds you can move across all your alternative procedures projects, and excess funds you can keep for other eligible uses. It is available only for large projects.
What FEMA requires
  • Standard procedures fund the pre-disaster size, capacity and function of a damaged facility based on actual costs.
  • Section 428 lets FEMA fund large permanent work projects on fixed, capped estimates through alternative procedures. They can only be applied to large projects.
  • Alternative procedures let applicants consider their community’s hazards, risks and vulnerability, with less itemized cost tracking and more flexibility in funding and restoration.
  • See the table for the main differences in funds, tracking and scope changes.
<table class="pt-table"><thead><tr><th>Consideration</th><th>Standard procedures</th><th>Alternative procedures</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Funds</td><td>Actual cost; no excess funds kept; funds only for the work in each project</td><td>Fixed cost; excess funds may be used; funds can move across all alternative procedures projects</td></tr><tr><td>Tracking</td><td>Track costs and work by work item and project</td><td>Track only total costs; show work relates to the approved scopes</td></tr><tr><td>Scope changes</td><td>FEMA approval needed for any change; track costs of changes</td><td>Approval only for buildings 45+ years old, ground disturbance, or work in or near water; no cost tracking for changes</td></tr></tbody></table>
Documentation

Under alternative procedures you track total costs for all alternative procedures projects together, and show that the work relates to the approved scopes of work, rather than tracking costs by work item and project.

Watch out · Govstar advice
The flexibility comes with a hard ceiling: if actual costs run over the fixed amount, FEMA pays nothing more. It suits applicants confident in their estimate and their ability to control costs.
PAPPG v5.0 pp. 289–290 · Stafford Act § 428
Read this in the PAPPG
Govstar summarizes FEMA’s Public Assistance Program and Policy Guide, version 5.0 Amended, for disasters declared on or after January 6, 2025. “Watch out” notes are Govstar practitioner advice, not FEMA policy. Govstar is independent and not affiliated with FEMA. This is general guidance, not legal advice.