Repair or replace · Interactive tool44 CFR 206.226(f) · Section 428 · Insurance

50% Rule Stress Tester

FEMA pays to replace a damaged facility only when the eligible cost to repair it is more than half the cost to replace it. The first numbers you have after a disaster, a FEMA RAPID Cost Estimating package, a ROM or your insurer’s initial statement of loss, all carry costs that this test leaves out and all carry wide uncertainty. This tool strips out what does not count, shows how far the ratio could move, and tells you whether the answer is safe to act on, including before you accept a Section 428 fixed-cost offer.

Clean the numbersRemove demolition, site work, soft costs, contents, mitigation and emergency work from both sides, as FEMA does.
Stress the ratioApply the accuracy of each estimate class and see whether the result could cross 50 percent.
Price the riskSee what a fixed-cost offer would leave you to cover if the estimate is low, and what you could keep if it is high.

1The rule in one minute

44 CFR 206.226(f)

A facility is repairable when disaster damage does not exceed 50 percent of the cost of replacing it to its pre-disaster condition and repair is feasible. If the eligible repair cost is more than 50 percent of the replacement cost, replacement is eligible. FEMA compares only eligible repair work with eligible replacement work, so both numbers are “clean” figures, not the totals on an estimate or a claim.

Numerator

Eligible repair cost

  • Include: repair of disaster-damaged elements, demolition needed to repair them, and code and standards upgrades that apply to the repair of those elements.
  • Leave out: demolition beyond what the repair needs, site work, soft costs (design and project management), contents, hazard mitigation, emergency work, and upgrades to undamaged elements.
Denominator

Eligible replacement cost

  • Include: building a facility of the same design, function and capacity, to the codes and standards that apply.
  • Leave out: demolition, site work, soft costs, contents, hazard mitigation and emergency work.
Not the same test as substantial damage. In a mapped floodplain, your floodplain administrator decides substantial damage under the National Flood Insurance Program by comparing repair cost with the building’s market value (44 CFR 59.1). A building can be substantially damaged and still fail FEMA’s 50% Rule, or the reverse. Run both.

2What each early number hides

Read before you divide
FEMA · 2024 method

RAPID Cost Estimating package

FEMA’s replacement scope and cost for a destroyed facility, built from aerial imagery, assessor records and other public data. See RAPID Cost Estimating.

  • It is a replacement number: use it on the denominator side.
  • Check that design, size and capacity match the pre-disaster facility.
  • Pull out demolition, site work and soft costs before you compare.
  • If the facility was badly damaged but not destroyed, you still need a repair estimate to run the test.
GovStar · Class R-2

ROM damage estimate

The ROM Damage Estimator splits the SOV value across UniFormat divisions and applies field damage percentages.

  • The direct damage line, without soft costs, is closest to the repair numerator.
  • Leave out the demolition allowance unless it is essential to the repair, and leave out emergency drying.
  • The SOV value is a starting replacement figure; trend it to today and remove site work.
  • About ±20–30%: good for screening, not for a decision.
Insurer · first report

Initial statement of loss

The adjuster’s first estimate or statement of loss is often the earliest line-item figure you have. It is built for the policy, not for FEMA.

  • It may be at actual cash value: add back recoverable depreciation to get repair cost.
  • It may be net of the deductible: add the deductible back.
  • Remove contents, business interruption, extra expense and debris removal; they are not building repair.
  • Early reports often miss hidden damage found once walls and roofs are opened.

3Stress tester

Interactive tool

Enter figures from your source. Leave a field at 0 if it does not apply. Everything is calculated in your browser; nothing is sent anywhere. Load the example to see how it works.

Source and accuracy
Sets typical accuracy below; you can change it.
A current, dated replacement value is usually tighter than the repair figure.
Repair side (numerator)
Insurance only: add back if the figure is at ACV.
Insurance only: add back if the figure is net.
Insurance only.
Damage found once finishes, roofs and systems are opened.
Replacement side (denominator)
SOV building value, RAPID package, appraisal or engineer’s estimate.
If the value is dated, trend it to the date of the estimate.
Funding and Section 428
Building and repair proceeds for this facility.
Essential demolition, site work and soft costs that are eligible project costs even though the test leaves them out.
Clean repair cost–
Clean replacement cost–
50% Rule ratio–
Stressed range–
0%25%50%75%100%
Clean ratioStressed rangeRatio from the raw source totals50% line
Enter a repair total and a replacement cost.

What moved the ratio

StepRepairReplacementRatio

Fixed-cost check (Section 428)

The stressed range is the widest result from moving repair and replacement in opposite directions by their accuracy. Accuracy defaults are GovStar planning guidance by estimate class, not FEMA figures. FEMA validates both estimates and makes the determination.

4Before you accept a Section 428 fixed-cost offer

Stafford Act §428, 42 U.S.C. 5189f

Under the alternative procedures, a large permanent work project can be funded on a fixed estimate instead of reconciled to actual cost. You give up true-ups in exchange for flexibility. That makes the repair-or-replace answer and the accuracy of the estimate a one-time decision: whatever class of number the offer rests on becomes your budget.

QuestionStandard large projectSection 428 fixed estimate
Cost overrunsEligible overruns can be added through a version or at closeoutYou agree to cover actual costs above the estimate
UnderrunsReturned at reconciliationFEMA may let you use excess funds for cost-effective risk reduction or to improve future PA operations or planning
Rebuilding something differentAlternate projects are generally reduced to 90 percent of the federal shareFEMA’s alternative procedures guidance removes that reduction
Grouping facilitiesOne project per facility or group of similar workFixed estimates can be consolidated into one subaward
Checking the estimateFEMA validates; differences are resolved through versions and appealsYou can ask for an independent expert panel when the eligible federal share is estimated at $5 million or more, and ask FEMA to consider a certified estimate from a mutually agreed licensed engineer
InsuranceActual and anticipated proceeds are deducted (44 CFR 206.250)Same: proceeds still reduce the award
Procurement and records2 CFR 200.317–200.327; records kept three years after the final expenditure report (2 CFR 200.334)Same rules apply to the work and to any use of excess funds
Rule 1

Do not fix a cost on an R-1 or R-2 number

A ROM, a statement of loss or a public-data package is a screening figure. If the stressed range crosses 50 percent or the overrun exposure is more than you could fund, ask for an engineer-validated (R-3) estimate before you agree.

Rule 2

Settle repair or replace first

The fixed amount follows the scope. Agreeing to a repair estimate when the facility is near 50 percent locks in the smaller number. Document the 50% calculation with the offer.

Rule 3

Reconcile insurance before you sign

Insurance still comes off the top. An early statement of loss is rarely the final settlement. Use the insurance documentation checklist so the anticipated amount FEMA deducts is the amount you will actually receive.

Closing out a fixed-cost project. You still certify completion and keep procurement and cost records. If you plan to use excess funds, FEMA’s training says to send a proposed scope and timeline to the recipient within 90 days of finishing your last alternative procedures project; the recipient forwards it to FEMA within 180 days. Obtain-and-maintain insurance requirements apply to work paid for with excess funds. See Alternative Procedures and Final Reconciliation and Closeout.
Watch the August 2026 PA memo. FEMA’s Administrator directed staff to develop estimate-based awards with limited reconciliation. If that becomes policy, more projects will behave like fixed-cost projects, and the class of the estimate behind each award will matter even more. See RAPID Explained.

5A staged route from trigger to closeout

Hybrid parametric approach

A hybrid approach uses fast, formula-based numbers to get cash and decisions moving, then replaces them with better numbers before anything is locked. Each step uses the right class of estimate for the decision in front of you.

R-1TriggerA hazard reading and SOV totals size reserves and early cash. No facility decisions.
R-2ScreenROM, registry model or RAPID package. Run this tester to flag facilities near 50 percent.
R-3DecideEngineer-validated estimate for every flagged facility. Settle repair or replace and the 406 mitigation scope.
R-4CommitAccept a fixed-cost offer only on an R-3 or better number, or keep the standard reconciled project.
R-5CloseActual costs, final insurance settlement, excess-funds plan and records.
Good use of parametric numbers

Speed where errors are cheap

  • Reserves, cash flow and declaration support.
  • Ranking which facilities to scope first.
  • Checking whether FEMA’s or the insurer’s first number is in the right range.
Poor use of parametric numbers

Decisions you cannot reopen

  • Repair-or-replace calls near 50 percent.
  • Fixed-cost offers and in-lieu payments.
  • Final insurance settlements and closeout amounts.

6Sources and related tools

Verify before relying
Repair vs. replacement44 CFR 206.226(f); FEMA Recovery Policy 9524.4 and its 2015 clarification; FEMA IS-1021 lessons on 50% Rule eligible costs; PAPPG v5, Chapter 8
Substantial damage44 CFR 59.1 (market value test, administered locally)
Alternative proceduresStafford Act §428, 42 U.S.C. 5189f(e)(1); FEMA Public Assistance Alternative Procedures guidance; PAPPG v5, Appendix G; FEMA IS-1000 on excess funds
Insurance44 CFR 206.250–206.253; FEMA PA Policy on Insurance
Procurement and records2 CFR 200.317–200.327; 2 CFR 200.334

A planning and screening tool. FEMA validates eligible scope and cost and makes every repair-or-replacement determination. Not engineering, insurance or legal advice and not FEMA guidance. GovStar is independent and not affiliated with FEMA.